Is There a Better Option Than SodaStream? Comparing Top Home Carbonators

SodaStream has long been the household name in home carbonation — practically synonymous with sparkling water makers. But with sleek new models and innovative features hitting the market, it’s worth asking: Is SodaStream still the best choice for fizzy drink fans?

Let’s break down how SodaStream stacks up against its competitors: Drinkmate, Ninja Thirsti, and the high-end Aarke. We’ll compare them on carbonation power, CO₂ efficiency, flavour flexibility, and overall value — so you can find your perfect match.

🥇 SodaStream: The Industry Standard (But Not Without Limits)

Best for: Beginners and casual users and any off brand would be similar and budget friendly like FIZZpod, Vevor and more.
CO₂ compatibility: Standard 60L twist-in or proprietary quick-connect cylinders
Flavour options: SodaStream syrups or add your own after carbonation
Carbonates: Water only

SodaStream is popular for a reason: it’s simple, sleek, and easy to use. Most models use the standard 60L twist-in CO₂ cylinders, which are widely available and compatible with other brands like Drinkmate and Aarke.

However, newer models like the Terra and Duo use SodaStream’s proprietary quick-connect cylinders, which simply click into place. While convenient, they come with two drawbacks:

Limited refill options – You’re mostly stuck with SodaStream-branded cylinders, which may not be refillable at local shops or through third-party services.
No cross-compatibility – If you switch brands later, those proprietary cylinders won’t work.

Bottom line: SodaStream is a great entry-level choice, but its newer models may limit your flexibility and cost more over time.

🚀 Drinkmate: More Fizz, More Freedom

Best for: Fizzy drink lovers and creative experimenters
CO₂ compatibility: Standard 60L twist-in cylinders
Flavour options: Add any flavour or carbonate pre-mixed drinks
Carbonates: Water, juice, cocktails, wine, coffee, and more

Drinkmate is a standout for people who want more than just sparkling water. It lets you carbonate nearly any liquid — sparkling lemonade, fizzy iced coffee, even a bubbly Negroni? No problem. Plus, it’s more CO₂ efficient, giving you more uses per cylinder.

Coming soon: Drinkmate will release a stainless steel model and bottle this summer, combining its top-tier functionality with a sleek, premium aesthetic.

Bottom line: If you want creative control, better efficiency, and serious fizz power, Drinkmate leads the pack.

🧠 Ninja Thirsti: Tech-Savvy and All-in-One (With a Catch)

Best for: Gadget lovers and convenience seekers
CO₂ compatibility: Standard 60L twist-in cylinders
Flavour options: Ninja flavour pods only
Carbonates: Water only

The Ninja Thirsti brings smart tech to the carbonation game. With customizable carbonation levels, chilled water, and one-touch flavour combos via pods, it feels like a sparkling water Keurig.

But there’s a catch — you’re locked into Ninja’s flavour pod system. No DIY syrups, no all-natural ingredients, no mixing your own drinks.

Bottom line: If you want tech-forward convenience and don’t mind staying in Ninja’s ecosystem, it’s a fun, modern choice.

✨ Aarke: Premium Design Meets Performance

Best for: Design enthusiasts and minimalists
CO₂ compatibility: Standard 60L twist-in cylinders
Flavour options: Add your own after carbonation
Carbonates: Water only

Aarke is the sleek Scandinavian entry into the carbonation space, known for its stainless steel body, premium materials, and minimalist design. It’s often seen as the “Apple” of sparkling water makers — stunning on the counter, with durable, high-quality construction.

While it only carbonates water, it offers a satisfying manual lever operation and a premium feel that sets it apart.

Bottom line: If style and durability matter as much as function, Aarke is a refined, high-end pick.

⚖️ The Verdict: Which Sparkling Water Maker is Right for You?

Feature	SodaStream	Drinkmate	Ninja Thirsti	Aarke
Carbonates other liquids	❌	✅	❌	❌
CO₂ efficiency	Moderate	High	Moderate	Moderate
Flavour flexibility	✅	✅	❌ (pods only)	✅
Tech features	Basic	Basic	High-tech	Manual only
CO₂ compatibility	✅ / ⚠️ (proprietary quick-connect on newer models)	✅	✅	✅

💡 Final Thoughts: What's the Best Alternative to SodaStream?

For the experimenter: Drinkmate offers the most freedom, with support for various liquids and an upcoming stainless steel version for design lovers.
For the tech lover: Ninja Thirsti brings sleek automation — but limits you to their pods and water-only carbonation.
For the minimalist: Aarke blends elegance and functionality with a durable, high-end build.
For beginners: SodaStream remains a safe, user-friendly choice — just watch out for the proprietary quick-connect models.

Bonus Tip for Canadians:
All these machines (except SodaStream’s quick-connect models) use the same standard 60L CO₂ cylinders. In many cities across Canada, you can exchange them easily. In the GTA, FizzyDelivery.ca even offers home delivery and swaps. Other cities like Vancouver, Calgary, Montreal, and Ottawa may have similar local options — check online or ask your local beverage store.

Bottom line: The home carbonation market is fizzing with great options. Choose the one that suits your style — whether that’s maximum versatility, top-tier aesthetics, or smart convenience. 🥤✨